
By JIM BUTLER
Twenty years after it began, a suit is back in Judge Monique Rauls’ court to decide how and when more than $17 million in legal fees and interest will be paid.
The litigation was filed in 2006 by landowners in the Catahoula Basin who claimed their property rights were adversely and illegally affected by water level changes due to Black/Red River navigation.
Steve and Era Lea Crooks (he was for a long time LaSalle Parish Clerk of Court) led the complaint by Catahoula Lake-area property owners.
A landmark ruling in 2016 declared the lake not a lake but an overflow area and that property between the low- and high-water points was private, not public, therefore subject to payment for the taking by the navigation changes, as well as for mineral (oil and gas) royalties.
Landowners in the class action were designated as Lake (property in the immediate area of impact) and Swamp (holders more downstream).
Ad Hoc Judge James Boddie Jr., retired from the bench in Morehouse/Ouachita Parishes, heard the case.
He awarded the Lake holders about $33 million for land and royalty loss and Swamp holders $9.5 million, all to be paid into a common fund for class members The land total is about 31,000 acres.
Subsequently in 2017 Boddie determined legal fees to be $22 million, 75% payable by the state and 25% by the plaintiffs’ common fund, with legal interest accruing.
Plaintiffs’ counsel at the time, according to court records, were the Gold firm in Alexandria, a Jonesville firm and a Columbia firm.
Before the ink was dry on the judgment (not any checks) the state appealed, telling the 3rd Circuit the federal government, not the state, took the acreage in question and the common fund of the class should be 100% liable for the legal fees, not the state. The court agreed.
Then in 2020 the Louisiana Supreme Court ruled the state statute of limitations on contested expropriation had been reached before filing, nullifying the bulk of the award.
So the plaintiffs had won but found their reward substantially reduced.
In 2022 Crooks broke from the class, hiring a Shreveport firm as counsel to argue for a reduction in the legal fees award in light of the reduced common fund totals The class counsel argued the contrary, that the original 2017 fees setting could not be changed.
In June 2024 the Supreme Court ordered the trial court, by then Judge Rauls, to reconsider Boddie’s 2017 fee determination.
Six months later she set the legal fees at $5.57 million plus interest.
As expected class counsel appealed the $17 million reduction to the 3rd Circuit.
In March this year that court determined Rauls was too low, and put the fees at $22.2 million using an established legal multiplier formula.
That ruling determined 13,108 billable hours were involved. It also set the land value of the common class at $68.3 million and royalties at $9 million.
As October closed the Supreme Court made the final call, ruling the circuit court multiplier too high and fixing the fees at $16.7 million plus interest since the 2017 initial setting.
The majority acknowledged the fee total exceeds the value of the recovery award but noted the beneficial asset of 22,000 acres involved in the Crooks petition, value at estimated $3,100 an acre.
Justice John Weimar dissented, saying the multipliers are not applicable in this instance and the Rauls setting was proper.
Now it’s back to Rauls, who is charged with deciding what reserves should be maintained in the common fund and how the attorney fees will be paid.