The logic is irrefutable.
Now that Centenary, as of this fall, and Louisiana Christian, for over two decades now, are playing football, why aren’t they scheduling each other? Or going to take on Grambling and Northwestern State
The Tigers and Demons have NCAA Division I Football Championship Subdivision teams. Yes, there’s a big difference between that level and the Gents’ resumption of football as a Division III program, along with the Wildcats’ newfound NAIA Division I status (LCU was in NCAA Division III in all sports until last year, when it shifted football to the NAIA ranks – doesn’t seem to be much difference, except a shorter path to the postseason and longer regular-season road trips).
Not suggesting that the other two 318-area code football programs, Louisiana Tech and ULM, should be inviting Centenary or LCU to come play. There’s enough of a resource gap between them and their FCS neighbors, a difference which would be magnified many times over considering a collision with the Gents or Wildcats.
But it is hardly incomprehensible to bring the Gents or Wildcats to NSU or the Mighty G from time to time, starting in 2025, since 2024 schedules are already set in place.
All it takes is reconsidering a flawed mindset.
That happened a half-century ago, in what was then known as State Fair Stadium in Shreveport, in 1974 when Grambling and Northwestern squared off in the first Deep South collision of a predominantly Black (nowadays known as HBCU) program and a mostly white university in the holy sport of football. That barrier-breaking had happened just a few years earlier in hoops in NAIA playoffs, and in baseball.
It was at the time an infinitely bigger deal than this would be. It went great. A crowd estimated at over 30,000 saw a thrilling 14-13 Grambling win still fondly remembered.
Nowadays, we’re not talking about a societal milestone, just some football games that would have benefits for each side.
First, the obvious upside. It doesn’t even take half a tank of gas to go back and forth between Shreveport and Grambling or Natchitoches. Same is true for the round trip from Pineville to Eddie G. Robinson Stadium or Turpin Stadium.
Team travel costs: virtually nil. No doubt, it would produce better than normal visiting fan counts. Probably a fair chance for more Grambling or NSU supporters to show up, too – because their teams are absolute locks to win, and the visiting teams’ rosters will include lots of young men from nearby.
From the Centenary or LCU perspective, the incentives are simple: they’ll make more money from the game guarantee than they will in a year of collecting home game admissions, and spend very little of it traveling to play. The resulting exposure and buzz around the games will resonate far past that weekend and benefit much more than football for those small colleges.
The perspectives are different for the G-Men and Demons.
Grambling has played programs like Langston – now a conference cousin of Louisiana Christian’s in the Sooner Athletic Conference – for years, mostly at home but at times at neutral sites. This fall the Tigers will welcome Division II Tuskegee in a great matchup between two of the best known and distinguished HBCU’s.
Northwestern hasn’t played a lower-division opponent since 2019. The Demons have never played an NCAA Division III foe in football, and since going NCAA Division I FCS in 1977, have hosted one NAIA team, Langston in 2013 (a 37-0 NSU romp).
The Tigers have no interest in the FCS postseason. The annual Bayou Classic is their showcase game, and it hopefully leads to the SWAC Championship game and even, as it did a couple of times under former coach Broderick Fobbs, to the Celebration Bowl, the HBCU championship contest.
The Demons do hope to eventually find their way back to the FCS playoffs, something not done in 20 years. First, they need to focus on simply posting a winning season, something not accomplished since 2008. That’s right, a spirit-obliterating 15 consecutive seasons below .500 or at break-even (2013, 2014). NSU has scheduled uphill, playing only two lower-division opponents in the past 10 years while facing at least one higher-level foe every year, including LSU, Texas A&M and the like.
This year, the Demons’ five-game non-conference slate includes perennial FCS playoff entry Weber State and a Southeast Missouri team with three playoff trips in the last six years, along with two FBS programs (Tulsa and South Alabama). Not to overlook the home game with Prairie View, who has won at least 5 games in every full season over the past decade.
Suffice to say, a home date with Centenary or LCU would be a welcome fit any time in the forseeable future for win-starved Northwestern.
Not saying it should happen every fall – not saying that’s a bad idea, ether — but suggesting that in every five seasons or so, it sure makes sense to see Centenary making short trips east on I-20 and south on I-49, and LCU also staying in the 318 as a visiting team.
Plus, let’s not overlook the obvious: LCU vs. Centenary, home and home. Don’t hair-split over NAIA/Division III complications. The Wildcats just last year popped D3 East Texas Baptist 34-14 in their home opener in Pineville. The mature, never-better LCU program would plaster Centenary for at least a few seasons, home or away.
There’s no negative to getting this series established. The schools still compete in every other sport in Red River Athletic Conference circles.
And it makes infinite sense for the Wildcats to make an occasional jaunt up to Natchitoches. It’s nothing new for Louisiana Christian to travel to FCS foes – recent ones include long bus rides to Stetson (Deland, Fla., next to Daytona Beach) and Abilene Christian, along with a comparatively short journey to Lorman, Miss., to play Alcorn State.
Besides, those frisky Wildcats, fresh off a sensational 9-2 season and an NAIA playoff appearance, are traveling to play Houston Christian this fall. That’s the HCU Huskies – who play in the Southland Conference along with NSU.
If that can happen, why can’t this?
Contact Doug at sbjdoug@gmail.com